When we moved here 35 years ago, we got a dog, a lovely long-haired german shepherd with a sweet disposition. Shelly would do anything for my husband. She worshipped him and his friend. But she ignored me. Even though I fed her. Even though I walked her. Even though I was really nice to her.
When Tom and Jim swam out to the raft in the lake, Shelly was so devoted to the two of them that she learned how to swim right there and then, so she could be with them. I called her as she splashed awkwardly out to the raft, but she ignored me.
Finally after about three weeks of this, I got fed up. Once again, Shelly'd ignored me when I'd called her to come. That was enough. I growled at her in a no-nonsense voice and gestured to her, demanding that she come and sit down. She looked a bit surprised, but she came to me and sat down. From that day on, she was my dog.
My instinctive reaction to demand respect from her was exactly the signal that she could understand and appreciate. Being too nice gave her the wrong signal and only confused the issue.
Friends used to tell me that I was too nice with the people in my life. I used to hate saying "No," to even when the workload would be uneven. I like to help out. Often my mistake was in thinking that the ones I was helping would be just as generous with their time or energy. But it didn't work that way. They seemed to operate under a different set of rules. Being too nice gave them the wrong signal and confused the issue.
Dog to dog, communication is clear. The alpha demands respect by taking a specific posture. His stance and the straight way he looks at the other dog asserts his position. If the other dog doesn't respect the posture, he'll move ahead to a warning growl. This isn't anger, it's a signal that the other dog understands. If the other dog still doesn't get the message, the alpha will spell it out.
This sequence works in person to person interaction, too: First the confident posture. Then, if that is ignored, a warning growl like the one I gave Shelly.
At a special family celebration, every time Sarah was asked to help out in the kitchen, she ignored the request with a toss of her hand. "I'll be right there," she promised. "Janet, can you help out until I get there?" This was her pattern in the past. She'd promise to help and never show up. In the past, I would have stepped right in to fill the gap out because I'm nice. This time I decided not to be quite so nice. I had enough to do as it was. I kept busy and ignored her. Just like an alpha dog would go about his own business. Her inaction was not my concern. When I didn't jump, she said, "Janet, I'm just going to be held up for a couple of minutes." I turned straight to her with a confident stance and said, "No." No anger. No guilt. No resentment. Just a firm, soft-spoken, "No."
If my stance had been apologetic, she'd get a mixed message from me. If I allowed her to steamroller me, that would give her the message that my needs don't count. Kindness, fairness and compassion take an important role. But if I'm too nice, I risk being misunderstood.
It may be easier for dogs. It worked for Shelly and I. We had many happy years together - years when I was nice to her - but not so nice that she got the wrong message.
Back to
Janet's website.